Your privacy is a PRIMARY consideration of AskDrSears.com. Your
e-mail address is used ONLY by AskDrSears.com for the purpose of
announcing news, events and special offers available only
AskDrSears.com registered users.
Baby Sling Closeout Special! Extended through May until sold out!
Buy a baby sling for a friend and get one free for yourself or get just one at 50% off.
Buy one get one free Discount code: freesling
Or 50% off your babysling Discount code: halfoff expires: 05/30/08
*Not valid in conjuction with any other offers.
Your privacy is a PRIMARY consideration of AskDrSears.com. Your
e-mail address is used ONLY by AskDrSears.com for the purpose of
announcing news, events and special offers available only
AskDrSears.com registered users.
"Got milk?" ask the ads. "Do you really need milk?"
ask parents. There is a place for milk and dairy products in the American diet,
as long as you choose the right kinds. Here are some questions you may have
about milk for kids and grown-ups.
QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE ABOUT MILK NUTRITIONAL BENEFITS
Why is milk so good for children? While cow's milk is really
designed for baby cows rather than baby humans, it's a nutritional staple in the
diet of many cultures. For children who are not lactose-intolerant or allergic
to dairy products, milk is one-stop shopping for nutrition. It contains nearly
all the basic nutrients that a growing child needs: fats, carbohydrates,
proteins, vitamins and minerals (except iron). While it is true that most of the
nutrients in milk can be gotten easily from other sources, such as vegetables,
legumes, and seafood, milk puts them all together in a convenient package.
Realistically, children eat or drink dairy products in greater amounts and more
consistently than other foods. While whole milk is not the only way to get
calcium in a child's diet, it's the most practical way. Good luck serving your
child a breakfast of calcium-rich broccoli, kale, and sardines. Specifically,
these are the nutritional benefits of milk, per 8-ounce glass:
Protein: 8 grams.
Carbohydrates – lactose, 11 grams
Fat: Depending on what kind of milk you choose (nonfat to whole milk), milk
contains anywhere from negligible amounts of fat in non-fat milk to eight grams
of fat per 8-ounce glass in whole milk.
Calcium: 300 milligrams or 35 percent of the RDA
for school children. Note that the percentage of calcium absorbed from dairy
products is much higher than that absorbed from most vegetables. Milk is
fortified with vitamin D, which boosts calcium absorption.
Vitamin B2 (riboflavin): 8-ounces of milk supply half the RDA for children
under three years, one-third of the vitamin B2 requirement for school-age
children, and one-fourth the requirement for teens and adults.
Vitamin B-12: 30 percent RDA for children
Zinc: one eight-ounce glass, 10 percent RDA for children
Vitamin D: 25 percent RDA for children and adults
Vitamin A: 10 percent RDA for children and adults
While milk isn't the perfect food, it still delivers a lot of nutrition in
all its various forms, such as cheese, cottage cheese, and yogurt. Besides, milk
and dairy products are foods that kids will eat and drink willingly. Despite the
bad press about milk, it has a lot of good nutritional things going for it.
I worry about allergies. We have a
lot of allergies in our family and I'm concerned that my child may develop milk
allergies. How common are these and how do I recognize them? Milk allergies are
over-diagnosed by the general population and under-diagnosed by doctors. The
real incidence of milk allergies lies somewhere between the folklore and the
skeptical view of many physicians. Around five percent of children and adults
seem to be either allergic to milk or intolerant of it. One carefully controlled
study showed that 75 percent of infants under one year of age were allergic to
cow's milk. Cow's milk allergy is more likely to develop in children who have a
family history of milk allergy. The good news is that of the approximately two
percent of children who are truly allergic to milk, many will outgrow this
allergy by the time they are two or three-years-old.
The protein in cow's milk is what provokes the allergies. Because milk is a
species-specific protein, cow's milk is suited to bovine intestines. Exposure of
human intestines to bovine protein may cause irritation and damage to the
intestinal lining, allowing these allergenic proteins to be absorbed into the
circulatory system. The immune system recognizes these proteins as foreign and
attacks them, causing the usual allergy symptoms of wheezing, runny nose, or a
red, rough, sandpaper-like rash, especially on the cheeks. Milk allergies are
often the underlying cause of repeated colds and ear infections, due to fluid
building up in the respiratory passages, sinuses, and eustachian tubes of the
ears. Milk allergy has been implicated in subtle behavioral changes, such as
irritability and nightwaking. Research has even shown that the allergic proteins
in milk (beta lactalglobulin) can pass through a breastfeeding mother's milk
into her baby and cause some babies to react with colicky symptoms. The colic-
cow's milk connection should be suspected as a
possible cause of fussy behavior in an otherwise, normal breastfed baby. The
allergic reaction between the milk protein and the intestinal lining can cause
minute gastrointestinal bleeding
(sometimes so slight that it is missed) and be a subtle cause of anemia in infants and young children.
Chronic milk allergy can also weaken the intestinal lining, allowing foreign
substances into the bloodstream that would ordinarily be screened out, a
condition known as the leaky gut syndrome.
Since true milk allergy involves the protein in the milk, the fat content of
the milk should not affect allergy symptoms. People who are allergic to milk may
be able to tolerate cheese or yogurt, or milk in baked goods. When milk is
heated, the proteins become less allergenic. (See related topic )
I've heard about lactose
intolerance. Is this a common problem with milk? Like milk allergy, lactose
intolerance is usually an over-diagnosed or a self-diagnosed problem. Lactose,
the sugar in both human and cow's milk, is normally digested by the intestinal
enzyme, lactase, which breaks the lactose down into glucose and galactose. Some
infants, children, and adults are deficient in this intestinal enzyme and thus
cannot absorb lactose. When the amount of lactose in the diet exceeds the supply
of lactase in the cells of the intestinal lining, the undigested lactose travels
down the intestines. There bacteria digest some of the lactose, but the rest
ferment and are converted into the gas, carbon dioxide, which causes bloating
, diarrhea, and abdominal
pain, and to lactic acid, which accounts for the red, irritated, burn-like ring
around the anus, especially noticeable in lactose-intolerant children. Other
more subtle symptoms are: headaches, fatigue, and bad breath.
Lactose intolerance is rare in infants, but more common as people get older,
so there is some biochemical basis for the idea that you outgrow your need for
milk. There are degrees of lactose intolerance, depending on the supply of
lactase in the gut. Some children and adults can tolerate one glass of milk, but
not two or three; or they can drink milk with a meal, but not separately on an
empty stomach. Many can tolerate yogurt and cheese,
but not milk as a beverage. (The lactose in fermented yogurt is somewhat
predigested.) Lactose intolerance is more common than allergy to the protein in
milk. Allergic symptoms usually involve the skin and respiratory systems,
whereas lactose intolerance is limited to abdominal symptoms. Lactose-
intolerance is especially prevalent in Asians, Hispanics, and African-Americans.
In fact, it is estimated that around three-fourths of the world's population
experience some degree of lactose intolerance.
Lactose intolerance may appear after the intestinal lining has been injured
by allergy or infection. This is called secondary lactose intolerance, and it
lasts only until the intestinal lining is healed. It is especially common in
children after a diarrhea-producing viral illness and the reason for delaying
the introduction of milk during the recovery stage.
If you are lactose-intolerant, try these strategies for getting the
nutritional benefits of milk into your diet:
Avoid lactose-containing dairy products for a couple weeks and then
gradually increase the amount you consume, beginning with a tablespoon of milk
and doubling the amount every few days until you reach your tolerance. Within a
few weeks, lactose-indigestion can turn into digestion.
Drink your milk in smaller more frequent servings.
Drink reduced-lactose milk, such as Lactaid, or take a lactase capsule along
with the milk.
Drink or eat dairy products with meals rather than solo to give your
intestines a better chance to digest the lactose. Anything that slows the
transit of food through the intestines gives the lactase-containing cells more
time to do their job.
Some dairy products contain more lactose than others. Here's a general
guide, ranked from most to least in lactose content:
Does milk contain a lot of fat? Yes and no, depending on whether you use
whole, lowfat, or skim milk. Since milk is an animal product, most of the fat in
milk is saturated. So you can scratch whole milk from a heart-healthy diet. A
glass of whole milk contains five grams of saturated fat, two-percent milk
contains 2.9 grams of saturated fat, and a glass of one percent milk contains
1.6 grams of saturated fat. An 8-ounce glass of whole milk also contains 23-31
milligrams of cholesterol, and three glasses of whole milk contain about the
same amount of cholesterol as one lean ground beef patty. In contrast, a glass
of one-percent (lowfat) milk will contain only ten grams of cholesterol. Three
glasses of milk will contain 30 milligrams of cholesterol, only one-tenth of the
maximum 300 milligrams a day recommended for an adult and only one-fifth of the
maximum 150 milligrams a day recommended for an average pre-school child.
Cow's milk does not contain any of the essential fatty acids necessary for
brain and body growth in young children. The fat composition of milk depends
upon the composition of the fat in the cow's feed, and the essential fatty acids
from the cow feed may be hydrogenated or saturated as they pass through the
cow's four stomachs. The fats in cow's milk even contain trans fatty acids, and
the amount depends upon the season of the year the cow is grazing (up to six
percent in the summer and three percent in the winter). As you can see, there
are many good reasons for choosing lowfat or skim milk over two-percent or whole
milk.
Is the warning not to drink milk when you have a cold an old doctor's tale?
Yes and no. Some people do make more mucus when they drink milk, and any high-
fat food may produce a sensation of thicker secretions in the back of the
throat. Yet, the mucus-producers are probably those that are allergic to milk.
Separating out milk-allergic persons, research fails to show any correlation
between drinking milk and mucus production during a cold. In conclusion, you
need extra fluids during a cold, anyway, so if you're not allergic it's okay to
drink a few glasses of lowfat milk.
I've heard there is a link between cow's milk and diabetes. Is this true?
Possibly. Studies comparing diabetes with the general population have shown a
statistical correlation between young children drinking milk and the later onset
of insulin-dependent diabetes. Further studies are needed, but researchers
speculate that the early introduction of cow's milk may cause an immune reaction
in the body. By some biochemical quirk, the protein in cow's milk (bovine serum
albumin) is similar to the natural proteins in the pancreas, the organ that
manufactures insulin. Researchers theorize that some people produce antibodies
in reaction to cow's milk protein that attach themselves to the insulin-
producing cells in the pancreas, eventually destroying them and leading to
diabetes. In one statistical study, insulin-dependent children had elevated
levels of anti-bovine serum albumin antibodies, but the control children only
had a small amount of these antibodies in their blood.
It's prudent to delay the introduction of cow's milk to breastfed infants and
children in the following situations:
a strong family history of milk
allergies
a strong family history of Type I (insulin-dependent or juvenile
onset) diabetes
any indications the child may have milk allergies
The possible connection between diabetes and cow's milk can't be all that
strong, since over 99 percent of the baby boomers who were raised on cow's milk
formulas have not gone on to develop insulin-dependent diabetes. So it looks
like we're back to the science of common sense. Cow's milk is meant for baby
cows. Human milk is better for human babies.
The studies implicating cow's milk in a child's diet with a higher incidence
of later illnesses are preliminary and of concern, but they should not be
interpreted to mean that children should not drink cow's milk (with some
exceptions). It's entirely possible that cow's milk loses by default; that is,
the link between the consumption of cow's milk at an early age and the
development of later illnesses may not be directly due to the cow's milk but
rather to the absence of breastmilk in the child's diet in the first one or two
years.
Is it true that children and adults have more medical problems with the more
milk they drink? Possibly. Compared with breastfeeding infants, cow's milk (and
formula) fed infants have more middle-ear infections, more upper respiratory
tract infections, and more intestinal infections. And there is the possible
diabetes/cow's milk connection described above. There are those who would make
milk the scapegoat for just about every ailment imaginable – from bedwetting to
hyperactivity – but there is no scientific evidence for a cause-and-effect
relationship between milk-drinking and any of these other illnesses. In fairness
to much-maligned milk, in our opinion, any connection between cow's milk and
disease is probably more a result of the absence of breastmilk in the infant's
diet than it is a reaction to the presence of cow's milk.
I heard that milk can contain a lot of pesticides, hormones, and antibiotics.
Is it safe? The safety of milk depends on who's interpreting the data. While
milk-bashing is popular among consumer groups, the government (with the support
of the American Dairy Council) has tried to foster a pure image for the sacred
cow. Cow feed undoubtedly contains pesticides, and cows are given antibiotics to
keep them from getting sick and hormones to increase their milk production.
Whether or not these substances show up in standard milk (which is supposed to
be tested for detectable residues) is uncertain. Be sure. Buy certified organic
milk, which means there were never hormones or antibiotics in the cow feed and
the milk was protected from pollutants during processing.
NUTRITIP: Healthier Milk
Buy certified organic milk. It doesn't contain antibiotics or
added bovine growth hormone (BGH).
AskDrSears.com is intended to help parents become better informed consumers
of health care. The information presented in this site gives general advice
on parenting and health care. Always consult your doctor for your individual
needs.